There's a difference between being a good and helpful person, and being a person who takes unnecessary risks who will eventually get herself killed. You have two children who are counting on you (and only you, from what it sounds like!). You can't take the risk that the guy who looks like he's having car trouble is really a serial killer. You just can't. I never, ever stop to help people when I'm alone with my children. Ever. I will stop if my husband or someone else is with me, but I can't defend myself and I won't take the risk. You shouldn't either.

When I see someone who appears to need help, I will roll down my window a little and offer to call for them on my cell. Or sometimes, like on the highway where I can't stop, I will just call 911 and have the dispatcher send someone.

You aren't responsible for every random person who runs out of gas. You ARE responsible for your kids. There are people who are paid to help others (police, etc.). Send them, keep driving, and keep yourself safe.

I'm glad you picked him up, but I would have been equally glad had you not. It's such a scary world these days.

You will be repaid for your kindness one day. I believe that.

Personally, I don't think you should stop when you're alone. I don't think it's about doing the right thing, I think it's about doing the right thing the right way.

There are other ways to help -- use your cell phone, stop and offer yours through the window, running for a gallon of gas and brining it back, etc.

But that's just me.

I like the thoughts behind your post, however. Helping others should is one place where we should never second guess ourselves.

Am I the only one who offers hope when it fits into my timeframe, you ask?

No.

It was so cold on Friday night. I was late. I was tired. I didn't have any money. So I didn't stop for a guy I saw on the street, and I can't stop thinking about him ever since. No, you are not the only one. But maybe by reading and talking and doing we can narrow the margin a bit. Thank you for writing this post.

Looks like everyone else covered most of what I had to say.

Each situation is different and needs to be considered on its own. Just how cold/hot is it outside? How much immediate danger is the stranded motorist facing? If things look really bad and I feel I can provide assistance that they can't wait for from trained professionals then I'll stop. Otherwise I put my cell phone minutes to good use.

I can't take every opportunity to help that I see. It's not reasonable on many levels.

But the ones I can do...your question is a good one. Do I take them? Do I take enough?

I do take some and that's something. It's a lot, actually, I think.

We go by gut, and if our gut is a well-developed and confident voice with good esteem, it works pretty well for us.

There are many avenues for helping out.

Julie
Using My Words

I think it would have been just as helpful if you were alone, if you called the police to come and help him on the side of the road.

Putting yourself in danger doesn't help anyone, right? Your big heart needs to be around to help more people. Thanks for writing this my precious friend.

You have a very good heart.

Many people have phrased my thoughts much better than I can,especially the first comment.

I just think that you should consider this: I know you have great faith, you believe in God and good things. SO, you have to believe in the real evil that is in the world, too.

It is sad, but also a fact.

It true when you said that you would have helped a dog. But dogs have never raped, kidnapped or tortured anyone.

It is conflicting but necessary that you BE SAFE.

P.S.
Phooey, I hit publish before I mentioned the most important part:
I am glad that you picked that man up and I believe he will repay the kindness as well. I am glad you were in a better position safety wise, so you could help.

Good post. While I am sure we miss opportunities to do good all the time, being aware will help cut down that number. You did good.

Heidi

I agree that there is a difference between helping others and putting ourselves at risk. But, where we draw the line is someone questionable. The question you raise to me are: Do I ever leave my confort zone to help others?

I think your instincts kick in and you stop when your sixth sense tells you they are a safe person. Unfortunately the world today has made us wary of the man with all his posessions in the grocery cart.... Help others, you need to to be you- but keep yourself safe, first and foremost....Calling the highway patrol for that man would have been a huge help for him.

You can't always stop. But instead of feeling bad when you can't, be glad for the times you can. And just maybe, your stop did make a difference and the next time you can't stop, your influence ensures that someone who can stop, actually does.

You can't be helpful when you are not comfortable.

There is no judgement to be had there.

You did good, friend.

Never stop when you are by yourself..but you are right, I think it's easier to consider it when it fits our time schedule..

Please don't do it by yourself..unless it's someone you know.

I agree with the general sentiment here, Jen...and I left a comment on that old post.

You have an obligation to your two girls to not stop when you are alone. But, you have helped many already by this post. I am sure there are many of us who will pay more attention now to those in need because of your post. I was one of those people in need on a cold dark night who ran out of gas once. There was also my wedding day 31 years ago when I ran out of gas that was one of my first posts!

I don't think you should stop when you are alone... You have two babies at home to think about. And though most strangers would probably never hurt you, you shouldn't take any chances with your life!!

I totally agree with what most of the others said. Keep yourself safe! My husband forbids me to stop when I am alone or with the kids. He stops and helps people and that is enough. I feel like I help others in my own way. If I see an older person, say, at the grocery store or church or anywhere that needs help carrying bags or opening a door, I help. I volunteer my time while my kids are in preschool helping out at a preschool for low income families. I could use the time away from my kids for myself, but I choose not too. It makes me feel good to spend time reading to those kids. I find many ways to help that don't put me in harms way, and yes, I go out of my comfort zone, and spend time that I don't really have doing it.

I was surfing blogspots for people who listed Van Morrison as one their favourite musicians.

Your musical taste rocks and so do your posts.

Have a nice day.

I help teach a Sunday School class and we are discussing the Good Samaritan. While discussing it, we are making an excuse chain. So far, it's HUGE! We've only been doing this for about 2 weeks. It's ridiculous how many excuses we come up with to help us JUSTIFY not helping someone...that being said, one of the biggest points we want to drive home with these children is that you help when it is SAFE TO HELP! If it is not safe to help (ie could get you killed), it's ok to call for "backup". So in the event you are feeling like you aren't helping, maybe you could make that the time you call for help? Just a thought. Love your blog!

But you weren't alone. You were with another person, which made it safe, and you really touched him and no doubt he went on (or will go on) to help someone else.

Don't beat yourself up over the what-ifs (I know - easier said than done). You remind me of my bff - so smart, and with a tendency to overthink things- and I mean that in a good way. Just, smart.

What you did was beautiful.

When I was about nineteen I was driving down the interstate and saw a car ahead of me start billowing smoke and pull over to the side. It was before the days of everyone carrying a cellphone. I stopped and gave the driver, who turned out to be a hispanic boy near my age, a ride to the courthouse where he was headed. He was uncomfortable, but very grateful and offered to give me gas money which I declined.

When I got back to my home my family was trying desperately to reach me. My step-sister had been driving by and saw me letting a strange man into my car. She was worried sick and had been calling everyone trying to reach me. I was lectured to pieces and told in no uncertain terms that giving strange people on the side of the road, rides is not a job for a women alone.

I have heeded that advice ever since, but several times I have been plagued by feelings of guilt because of it. I am a mother now though, and that makes my decision easier. That and knowing how furious my husband would be.

yes, i'm sure he will never forget your kindness. We all want to try and do good, to do better. It's just that little hair on the back of your neck that won't lie down sometimes......So glad it worked out for you- I know you felt that you were given the help, given the gift that night.

That was a kind thing to do and not something you could have done if you had been by yourself. But you weren't so it's all good.

I believe the best of people but I've also been attacked in broad daylight in a public park so I am also cautious.

And I'm sure he will help someone else, sometime, somewhere.

beautiful. these are hard, hard questions.

You can only do what you can do. You may have not brought him to a rest stop but maybe you would call someone for him.

I am sure he will pay it back.

Okay. First off, let me say this is a country song!

Second, I agree! There is a diffrence in taking a dangerous risk and then there's the side of caution, for you and your children.

Love ya!

I was faced with a similar situation a few months ago. I still think about it whenever I am at that grocery store - esp. in the parking lot.

Weighing the risks is a challenging task.

Once again, I find you amazing.

you're a good person, jenn.
xxoo

I pretty much second what everyone else said, that it's your girls you're responsible for and not people on the side of the road. It's awesome that you do stop when you can, but you have to think of your own safety, too. And sure, there are other ways to make sure those people get help without your being forced to put yourself at risk. Use your cell to call someone; if they've run out of gas, offer to run and get them a gallon or two; ask them if they need a tow truck that you can call. It doesn't have to be an all or nothing proposition to help people out of a jam, but not everyone who looks to be in a jam is really just in need of logistical help. That's why side of the road strandings are one of the biggest ways that people can be fooled into situations where strangers can hurt them. You're very kind, but you also need to be safe with yourself. It's not a lack of generosity or a coldness on your part. It's a balancing of priorities and something we all have to do.

Andrea

Thanks for pointing out how much fear we live in these days... You are helping others break through it -- with intelligence on your side.

Your writing slays me.

But stay safe, friend, stay safe.